The View from Castle Rock by Alice Munro

I hadn’t even heard of Alice Munro until a few weeks ago when a friend on my online book group suggested this as our June read. Alice Munro? Who is this woman? were my thoughts, so I googled, and found out that apparently everyone apart from me thought she was wonderful and she won the Booker International Prize in 2009. To be fair, it’s not really my fault that I had no idea who Alice Munro was, because in my English department at university if the words ‘Canadian’ or ‘American’ were placed in front of the word ‘Literature’, there were sharp intakes of breath all round and mutterings about oxymorons. So while I have dabbled in Margaret Atwood and Edith Wharton and Henry James and all the other usual suspects from across the pond, Alice Munro had slipped under my radar. And what a tragedy, because I wish that I had read everything she has ever written.

But I haven’t and so I am only able to talk about her and her work in regards to this book, which I have been reliably informed isn’t an accurate representation of her usual oeuvre. This is because it’s very biographical/autobiographical as it’s about her and previous generations of her family, but that’s not even really biography because she doesn’t actually know much about her Scottish ancestors who came over on a boat in the early 1800s.  So, she uses real people and real places and as much information as she can to construct lives and feelings and actions of people she is descended from and clearly wants to be able to bring to life again on the page. Though there necessarily has to be a fair whack of artistic licence when it comes to portraying these two hundred years dead ancestors, it doesn’t matter, because by the time you’ve started reading about them and caring about them and finding the way they lived and who they loved and the decisions they made fascinating and sad and moving, you don’t remember or even care that they’re Alice Munro’s great-great-grandparents and even though this is kind of real it’s also kind of not. It’s like Titanic, I suppose. We know someone like Rose and someone like Jack probably existed and went down with the ship, but whether they got together and yelled ‘I’m the King of the World!’ and then did some kissing on the ship’s prow doesn’t really come into it anymore by the time you’re sobbing, or shouting at Rose to stop singing and start swimming, whichever is your preference when watching this dire film.

If I could sum it up in a word, I’d say I’d found it all rather elegiac, especially the latter section of the collection, where the stories are about Alice’s grandparents, parents and herself, and so the people become accessible and there is not as much artistic licence, and the mistakes and regrets and tragedies and sheer drudgery that makes up their lives in windswept rural Canada are even more moving and absorbing. I got the sense that Munro was using this book as a way to find out more about herself, where she had come from, and where she had gone wrong. It was mournful but not depressing; these are people resigned to their lives and while aware that they could have, or should have, maybe, had more, they don’t pine for it. They get on with things. They marry, reproduce, work hard, die, and leave a trail behind them that Alice Munro has picked up and pieced together and written a remarkable string of connected stories that bring 18th and 19th century Scotland and 19th and 20th century Canada alive on the page. This book is as much about Alice Munro’s family as it is the tenacity of the human spirit throughout the ages, and it is wonderful.

I particularly enjoyed the fact that Alice Munro is directly related to James Hogg, of ‘Confessions of a Justified Sinner’ fame; this book is terrific for understanding the predestination beliefs of hard core Scottish Presbyterians in the 18th century, many of whom Alice Munro can count as her ancestors and whom she describes in a couple of early stories. I love the attitude of ‘we’re saved, so we can do what we want’. Not quite the point Jesus had in mind, I suspect.

Anyway, I digress…read these stories, they will blow you away. I’m now determined to track down all her other stories and devour them as quickly as I can!!! You can get your own copy here.



  1. Anonymous says:

    Booksnob,what a lovely post. and blog — although i don't really let meyself read it because it would make me ache to read all kinds of things i don't have time to read. i'm so pleased you fell in love with Alice Munro. She is exquisite. Her work is so extraordinary in its simplicity, i think. And I tend to think of her as very Canadian — i think it's the reserve and the restraint and severity, but with a touch of humour or wryness. My own mother is the same as age as AM. And although she didn't grow up in rural Ontario, she grew up in rural NB. And like AM, some of her ancestors were Scottish. There were moments in reading AVFCR which resonated with me because they reminded me of things my mother would have said, or things she described about growing up. (That line early on about how it's important to "not call attention to yourself" gave me great pause. I grew up hearing that!) And as someone who has moved away from her childhood home, i understand those conflicting feelings and desires you develop for and around it. Like you I loved it. the last story, I think, I found a touch disappointing. (The one about the crypt.) It seemed a bit more forced than the others. But she always leaves me feeling sad and satisfied. Elegaic is a wonderful description. Here's a cool article about AM by Margaret Atwood.

  2. Rachel says:

    Thanks Margot! I'm so glad you loved it too..noone else in our book club did! Thank you for the article, it's really interesting. I'm so glad you came by, come back again! I promise not to tempt you! Mwa ha ha!

  3. SilverSeason says:

    I liked the book, especially the second half which was more about her own life, growing up where it is not a good idea for a girl to be too smart. The tone is remote and simple, but doesn’t tell you too much. There are always unanswered questions, but she has made you care about the answers:

  4. Kinga says:

    I also keep hearing about Munro but I will definitely read something now.
    Speaking of Canadians – recently my book club discovered Robertson Davies and were enchanted by him. We couldn’t understand none of us ever heard of him when in Canada they read him in school.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s