A Mile of River by Judith Allnatt

Having been much impressed by Judith Allnatt’s second book, The Poet’s Wife, a few months ago, I was excited to read this, her debut novel. Set in the sweltering, drought hit summer of 1976 on a rural farm in the North of England, it tells the story of Jess, a seventeen year old girl desperate to escape the confines of her often suffocating family life. Jess’ father Henry is a proud and stubborn man; strict, violent and concerned merely with the running of his farm. As the weather gets hotter and the local river begins to dry out, the already dire finances of the farm are threatened to dangerous measures, making Henry even more prone to rages than usual. Jess’ mother, Sylvie, walked out on the family when Jess was a child and her younger brother Tom just a baby, and they haven’t heard from her since. As such, Jess must be a mother to nine year old Tom as well as running the house and helping her dad out with the farm. Anxious to do well in her school exams so that she can go to university and study medicine, as well as spend time with her friends and Martin, the boy she likes, her life is increasingly becoming a balancing act between the demands of her father, the farm, Tom, and school. When she disobeys her father to go out to the local fair and meet Martin, Henry’s wrath is such that he bans her from going to school and taking her exams. Her place, says Henry, is at home, and on the farm, and she shouldn’t want more than that. Devastated, Jess is forced to ever more desperate measures to secure a life for herself, but the last thing she expects is a shocking discovery one day as she walks along the banks of the river; a discovery that will throw her and her family’s life into turmoil she never could have imagined.

Alongside Jess’ story, we also hear about Sylvie’s life with Henry, through a journal Jess finds at the back of a drawer. Initially pleased to marry him and escape her own difficult home life, it’s not long before Sylvie realises that the passionate and loving man she married cares more for his farm than for her and their children. Like Jess, she longs for an independent life of her own, a way to express her creativity, meet people, and make friends, rather than be stuck alone in the farmhouse all day, with only Henry’s kindly father, who always does his best to work things out for Sylvie, for an ally. However, Henry doesn’t allow Sylvie to have a job or make friends, and he makes it clear that her place is on the farm, looking after him. When Sylvie finally does manage to get herself a job, Henry’s jealousy and anger are too much for Sylvie, and she runs away from him, never to return…though, as Jess always wonders, how could she have willingly left her beloved children behind?

This is a wonderful novel that is profoundly unsettling and excellently characterised, with many more terrific characters than I have space to describe. Jess is a heroine you can’t help but root for; she tries so hard to do what is best for everyone else, but at the same time, she can’t deny her own ambitions and desires. Devastated by her father’s lack of love for her, and by her mother’s abandonment, she is also badly treated by Martin and depended on by Tom. Her life is a constant struggle of walking on eggshells, deception, duty, and worry, and my heart broke for her as she tries to go through life with no mother to guide her and the weight of a world on her young shoulders to carry. All she wants is to be a normal teenager, and Henry’s cruel, violent behaviour annoyed me so much I wanted to reach into the pages and slap him. I kept hoping he would change his behaviour, have an epiphany of sorts, and let Jess have the life she had worked so hard for. I also kept hoping Sylvie would come back and make it all ok. However neither of these things happen, but the ‘why’ behind Sylvie’s abandonment and Henry’s attitude is revealed in a shocking twist that I certainly didn’t see coming, and the book is worth reading for this touch of brilliant plotting alone.

Judith Allnatt is a very atmopsheric, descriptive writer, and I felt like I too was milking in the barn alongside Jess, my clothes wet with sweat, the frustration and misery of another day spent under the tyranny of an abusive father filling my heart. I greatly enjoyed reading this, though I did have a couple of misgivings. Firstly, as it so perfectly captures the voice of a seventeen year old, I felt this should have been classified more as a ‘Young Adult’ novel. Secondly, I was frustrated by Jess’ depicted dependency on men. Jess’ happy ever after only comes after she has found a boy who loves her, and like her mother before her, she looks to boys to ‘rescue’ her from her troubled home life. I find this incredibly irritating, when girls are depicted in books as co-dependent, helpless creatures whose true happiness entirely depends on whether they are in a relationship or not. For a character who grew up in a home with a father who was both an abusive husband and an abusive parent, I did question Judith Allnatt’s decision to place Jess’ future happiness in the hands of yet another male figure. It seemed to somewhat negate the strength of character Jess had shown in the book, as both boys she dates are only really interested in her because of her looks and her willingness to have sex, and Jess is quite happy to go along with this. I would have liked this book even more if Judith Allnatt had let Jess be an independent woman, wanting to go off alone to university to work out who she was and what she wanted from life, on her own terms. As it was, I closed the book concerned that Jess would end up just like her mother; desperately throwing herself into unsuitable relationships in an attempt to find the security she had never had throughout her upbringing, and finding herself, through lack of maturity and self confidence, in the same position she was in before.

I received my copy of this book from the publisher, Transworld, and would be delighted to pass it on to another blogger! Let me know in the comments if you’d like it – anywhere in the world is fine – and I’ll draw a winner in a few days.



  1. KarenV says:

    I’ve been reading your blog for a while and really enjoy your reviews, as you seem to read things that I have on my “to be read” list! A Mile of River is on said list and I would love to have the chance to own a copy please 🙂

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Karen! It’s lovely to see a new face! Fingers crossed for you – I’ve entered you into the draw!

  2. Kathy says:

    Ohhhh I think I can guess what Jess discovers down by the river . . . but I would love a chance to find out if I’m right! 😉

    1. bookssnob says:

      Haha! Oh really?! Well let’s hope you get a chance to find out – fingers crossed for you win!

  3. Jenny says:

    No need to enter me–I just finished having a delicate conversation with my mother in which I explained very slowly and gradually that I had bought twenty new books at a book sale and would need to store them at her place along with all my others until I develop a Permanent Life Plan with an apartment and a job.

    BUT, this book sounds really good, if sad. I have a harder time than I used to reading about bad parents. I wish everyone could have good parents! Like my extremely patient book-storing parents! (But then I remember from reading books and experiencing life that not everybody can.)

    1. bookssnob says:

      Oh Jenny you are so funny! When I moved back in with my mum this year after living alone for five years…living alone and acquiring books by the cartload…she was shocked and appalled by the amount of books that kept materialising from my car. She couldn’t believe I had so many! Neither could I really. Permanent Life Plans need to be developed for me too, though I can’t see that happening any time soon!

      I know, I felt sad too. I have been lucky with my parents, even if they hate books!

  4. Mystica says:

    The book sounds as if its a true story and not just fiction. I would love to be given an opportunity to read. Thanks for your generosity.


    1. bookssnob says:

      You have been entered, Mystica! Fingers crossed for you too! 🙂

  5. Lex says:

    You raised such a good point. Why must Jess depend on men? Isn’t she supposed to be strong and fierce? Women should be portrayed in a different manner.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Lex! Yes – I get very frustrated by this. Though of course it must be because I am a bitter, frustrated, spinster! 😉 It also annoys me when people say that – as if I’m jealous of women being reliant on men – not likely!

  6. LizF says:

    I read this a few months ago and very much enjoyed it – as much because I was around Jess’s age in 1976 and remember the long hot summer very well – as because it is an excellent, atmospheric book.
    I see what you mean about it being a YA book and I might well suggest to my 16 year old daughter, that she takes a look at it should she get bored in the next month and a bit before 6th Form looms.
    Jess wasn’t unusual in seeking validation from men and boys – a lot of girls did then (still do now really, which is sad) and I remember a lot of otherwise bright girls, who thought more about ‘going steady’ than going to university, and for whom an engagement ring was more important than a career path!
    Not everyone went to university as a matter of course in the 70’s and a lot of things were still very male oriented then.

    1. bookssnob says:

      I’m glad you enjoyed this too – I didn’t realise there actually had been a drought in 1976 – it must have had extra meaning to you as you experienced it!

      That’s interesting – I didn’t think of it from that point of view and that Allnatt was trying to create a realistic outcome for Jess based on expected paths for women in the 70’s. That makes me less angry about it now! Thank you, Liz!

  7. savidgereads says:

    This sounds like its a rather good book. I have to say don’t enter me into the draw for it though as I have rather too many books on the TBR as it is hahaha. An interesting concept for a novel though, I never feel I know enough about the 1700’s, my knowledge between the Tudor period and Victorian times is DREADFUL!

    1. bookssnob says:

      It is a rather good book indeed Simon! But it’s the 1970’s not the 1700s!! I know nothing about that era either!

  8. Tracey says:

    Hi, great review, you certainly can write lady! would love a chance to read it myself..thank you

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Tracey! That’s very kind! I will enter you in with a chance of winning – fingers crossed!

  9. Darlene says:

    Best not enter my name in your draw, Rachel. I wanted to take a big stick to the computer just reading about these knuckle-scraping neanderthals in your review!

    On that note…have a great day!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Darlene! You are so funny! Yes – I think you’d fling the book across the room!!!

  10. Patty Weiser says:

    Sounds like a great book. I was disappointed to find it is out of print because you make it sound like such a good read.


    1. bookssnob says:

      Out of print? What a shame! Well I’ll enter you into the draw. Thanks for coming by Patty!

  11. Gill says:

    Various things happening here & I’ve only just caught up with your blog. If I’m not too late, I’d love to be entered into the draw for this book. Your review makes it a must-read for me.
    Incidentally I was interested to see your photos & comments about Royal Holloway as I was a student there from 1962-65. I loved my time there, but I expect it would seem very strange to you if you time-travelled back. Men were only students there after graduating. We lived in Founders, dined there & I went to lectures there – no need ever to leave the building if you didn’t want to! Amongst many other things, we were supplied with a bar of Knights Castille soap every few weeks!! If you want to know more, do e-mail me.
    Congratulations on the impending new beginning – I look forward to reading about your life in New York. Thank you for the pleasure I get from your blog. Gill

    1. bookssnob says:

      Hi Gill -no, I totally forgot I needed to do the draw so you are not too late!

      How wonderful! I LOVE hearing about the old days at good old Royal Holloway! My French teacher at school went in the 70’s and she used to regale me with marvellous stories of sit down dinners and iced buns for tea – no such luck for me! I can’t imagine just having Founder’s Building to explore – we felt hemmed in enough at the weekends, but at least there were other places on campus to explore!

      Thank you so much – it’s a pleasure to give you pleasure!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s