Morning Shows the Day by Helen Hull

You might have seen Helen Hull mentioned on The Persephone Post of late; Nicola Beauman has recently discovered this remarkable early to mid century American novelist and has been waxing lyrical about her. When Nicola wrote that she was her new favourite novelist, I immediately went off in search of more information. I couldn’t really find anything, so I went to ebay on the off chance that a cheap copy of one of her books would be listed. Book serendipity struck; a 99p copy of a rather battered 1930s hardback, Morning Shows the Day, was about to end. I swooped in, and a few days later it plopped onto my doormat. With no idea what to expect, I opened the rather musty smelling pages and began to read. Immediately I realised that I had struck gold; her prose is a blend of Willa Cather’s sparse, piercing clarity and Dorothy Whipple’s intuitive, sensitive portrayals of the soul and human relationships. Morning Shows the Day proved to be a beautiful, haunting and engrossing portrayal of the hopes and dreams of a group of young people from a bleak and faded turn of the century mid Western town; it’s a remarkable novel, and I really can’t believe that it, and all of Hull’s other novels, have been so forgotten.

The novel opens in a nameless town, not too far from Chicago, in the 1910s. For some it is a place of peace and prosperity; they live in large homes on quiet streets surrounded by shady trees, dress in furs and silks, have servants and go to dinners and dances.  For others, living in tumbledown clapboard shacks along the banks of the dirty river, life is a constant cycle of drudgery and poverty, struggling to make ends meet in dingy, uninhabitable homes that their wealthy neighbours are barely aware of. At the town’s High School, the children of both rich and poor are free to intermingle, and their contrasting dreams and ambitions, and ability to pursue them due to their family backgrounds, are the crux of the novel.

Tom Ellsworth and Eugenia Murray are the scions of the most profitable and high profile men in the town. Tom is lazy and selfish, but adored for his good looks and easy going manner. Eugenia is beautiful and fun loving, but also shallow and petty, and she won’t allow anyone to let her get in the way of what she wants. Elida Hawthorne, dark, striking, and a little unnerving, lives in a boarding house with her older sisters, and believes that her sex appeal is going to be her way out of a life of drudgery. She has set her eyes on Tom, but she wouldn’t also mind Robert Swift, the handsome, rebellious and volatile son of the town’s Preacher, who can’t wait to get out of the Midwest and away from the suffocating religiosity of his family home. Elida is not Robert’s only admirer, however; there is also Shirley Thomas, a bright, ambitious and pretty girl whose family are slipping ever further down the social scale, and who has dreams of escaping from the narrow confines of town life, preferably at Robert’s side. Seething with jealousy at Shirley’s admiration of Robert is Allen Collins, whose drive and determination are mocked by the likes of Tom and Robert, who could never understand the difficulties of Allen’s life. His mother is dead and his father is a drunk, and so in order to feed himself and keep a roof over his head, Allen has to work both before and after school, driving himself to hollow eyed, desperate exhaustion. His intensity frightens Shirley, but it attracts little Ruby Cutter, a plain girl from the riverside shacks, whose quiet and gentle manner make her overlooked and unappreciated by her schoolmates.

This motley crew of young people gradually grow up and go their own ways over the thirty year timespan of the novel. Their paths diverge and meet again, as some choose to stay on in the little town that grows with the boom of the American manufacturing industry, and others leave – for Detroit, Chicago and New York, in pursuit of bigger dreams. Happiness eludes many of them; the things they thought would fulfil them instead just leave them empty. Others are never brave or strong enough to forge a new path for themselves, and instead are trapped within the limitations of their own imaginations. As the band of teenagers grow into adults, some with children of their own, they come to realise that life is not as simple or as charmed as they thought it could be. As different and divergent as their paths have been, however, the little town is the tie that will always bind them, and is the compass that will always draw them home.

This really is a remarkable novel. It’s so poignant, and so evocative of a time in American history when you really could become whoever you wanted to be, no matter where you came from. As much as it moved me to watch children who had such dreams, passions, ambitions, and hopes grow into adults who were often defeated and limited by the choices they had made, it also inspired me by showing how much we are the creators of our own destinies, and that circumstances need not dictate our outlook on the world and our treatment of others. Helen Hull weaves a rich, intense and gloriously colourful tapestry of early 20th century American life, and her characters are perfectly fleshed out – so much so that I felt like I knew them by the end. Humanity and destiny are weighty subjects, but Hull handles them sensitively, deftly and with immense pathos. This is not a novel that deserves to be forgotten; it is touching and profound and striking in its honesty. I can’t praise it, and Hull’s writing, enough. What a discovery! I have more of her novels winging their way to me across the Atlantic as I write and I can’t wait to immerse myself in her this winter!

If you’re interested in tracking down Helen Hull’s novels, here are a few tips –

1. Helen Hull can also be listed as Helen R. Hull and Helen Rose Hull. This is still the right Helen Hull.

2. Helen Hull Jacobs is not the same Helen Hull.

3. If you’re in the US, her books are available pretty cheaply second hand on amazon or on ebay. In the UK, you can order some of her books cheaply second hand through, but they will be from American sellers so they’ll take a while to arrive. Doing it that way prevents you from having to pay exorbitant postal charges, however.

4. Two of her books, Quest and Islanders, are available through The Feminist Press.

5. Helen Hull was fairly prolific – one source mentions 17 novels – so there are a lot of her books out there. Here is a list (not exhaustive) of the books I have managed to verify are definitely by her:

Heat Lightning, Hardy Perennial, The Asking Price, Quest, Labyrinth, The Surry Family, Islanders, Frost Flower, Landfall, Morning Shows the Day, Uncommon People, Candle Indoors.

Happy hunting!


  1. Liz says:

    Perhaps someone should do a Wikipedia article on Helen Rose Hull. A search brings up only Helen Hull Jacobs, also an author it seems.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Maybe I will wade in, Liz!

  2. This is fascinating, Rachel! I love stumbling across a new author!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Miss Darcy, glad you enjoyed it! I hope you manage to track down one of her books!

  3. Charles Baker says:

    Your copy of Islanders arrive at my house yesterday; I will ship it International Priority Mail when I get back to my office at the university on Monday. I think you will be pleased with it, knowing your preference for gently read used copies of books; it is a hardcover, 1st edition!


    1. bookssnob says:

      Fantastic! Thank you so much Charles – I can’t wait to read it!

  4. Candyce says:

    I ordered it today! I love Dorothy Whpple and after your review, I can’t wait!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Brilliant! Let me know how you get on with it, Candyce!

  5. This book–and writer–sound like a new favorite waiting to be discovered.

    1. bookssnob says:

      She is fantastic Cath!

  6. This sounds like a great author. I will keep my eyes open for her.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Glad to hear it, Janet!

  7. Mystica says:

    Thanks for the post. It was so informative. Will be keeping an eye out for her.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Mystica – hope you can find some of her books and enjoy them for yourself!

  8. You’ve once again introduced this Yank to another author she has not met and will be on the lookout for, especially this book, Rachel, which seems to have been written in my own backyard. Thank you.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thank you, Penny – yes, I am sure it is set somewhere in the vicinity of you. I hope you can get hold of some of her books as I know you would love them.

  9. Geetanjali says:

    I like reading your posts because there’s always something new for me to learn here. I’m constantly finding out about new authors, the way they write, and what to look for in a good book.

    1. bookssnob says:

      How lovely of you, Geetanjali – I’m so flattered and glad to hear that!

  10. Virginia says:

    This novel sounds like just my kind of book. I will definitely be looking out for it and her other novels. Thanks for letting us know!

    1. bookssnob says:

      I think you’d love her, Virginia! Hope you can track some down!

  11. Simon T says:

    You sure know how to sell a book! If Nicola doesn’t ask you to write an introduction, she’s crazy.

    1. bookssnob says:

      You’re hilarious! I wish!

  12. Nicola says:

    Ooh interesting! She writes about the same area – the mid-west – as Cather. I will be checking out this writer. I agree with Simon, Nicola B should hire you!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Yes, she does, and she is very Cather-esque. I am certain you will love her, Nicola – try and get hold of one of her novels asap! Oh I am blushing! I’d love that!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Oooh I should get involved, thanks Liz!

  13. pmccmiller says:

    Hi Rachel. I’m so pleased that you like Helen Hull. Your review of Morning Shows the Day is a perfect combination of intelligence, careful reading, and enthusiasm. Here’s a basic list of novels:
    1922 Quest (Macmillan)
    1923 Labyrinth (Macmillan)
    1925 The Surry Family (Macmillan)
    1927 Islanders (Macmillan)
    1930 The Asking Price (Coward-McCann)
    1932 Heat Lightning (Coward-McCann)
    1933 Hardy Perennial (Coward-McCann)
    1934 Morning Shows the Day (Coward-McCann)
    1936 Candle Indoors (Coward-McCann)
    1939 Frost Flower (Coward-McCann)
    1940 Through the House Door (Coward-McCann)
    1943 A Circle in the Water (Coward McCann)
    1946 Hawk’s Flight (Coward-McCann)
    1953 Landfall (Coward-McCann)
    1958 Wind Rose (Coward-McCann)
    1960 A Tapping on the Wall (Dodd, Mead)
    1963 Close Her Pale Blue Eyes (Dodd, Mead)
    These are only the American editions. Many of the novels were also published in England. She also published about 65 short stories (mostly in magazines), edited several volumes of other people’s stories, edited several books about writing, published a short biography of Mayling Soong Chiang, and published several collections of her own stories and novellas. The two books easiest to get right now are the Feminist Press reprints of Islanders (1988) and Quest (1990), but there are many copies of the others floating around, easy to locate on the internet. I’m working on a Facebook page for Hull, which I hope will help in the promotion of Heat Lightning when Persephone publishes it. A Wikipedia article would be super. Let me know if I can be useful for that. Nicola can vouch for me as a reliable source! Love your blog. Best wishes.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thank you so much for this Pat – I’m delighted to ‘meet’ you (Nicola had told me about you!) and to have all of this information! I am so glad you enjoy my writing and I look forward to collaborating with you on a wikipedia page – I shall get that started!

      1. pmccmiller says:

        You might be amused to know that I discovered in one of my old files that she had to buy woolen underwear to survive London in 1931, where she’d gone on a Guggenheim fellowship to write Heat Lightning. I, too, am really looking forward to working together.

      2. bookssnob says:

        How funny! I didn’t realise that she had written Heat Lightning whilst in England…that makes it even more extraordinary that she managed to evoke the heat and dust of the Midwest so well!

  14. pmccmiller says:

    Inspired by your enthusiasm, I’ve put together the beginnings of a Helen R. Hull Facebook page, which is now posted. Lots more to come, but thanks for your prompting! Should have explained in previous post that I did my dissertation on Hull’s work, and am working on a biography. She’s fascinating. Looking forward to reading your blog and to more Hullery. Best wishes, Pat Miller

    1. bookssnob says:

      Brilliant, Pat! It’s so good to know that you are out there working on Helen Hull and raising her profile. I wish I had more time to do the same! I’m off to find the facebook page!

      1. pmccmiller says:

        FB is doing weird things with it–it’s ok (although very rudimentary so far) on my desktop as long as you click on Info, but from my iphone, the info page just repeats the bio entry as “description,” which then omits what I set up there as basic introduction. Don’t know what the problem is. But at least it’s under way! Thanks for your encouragement.

      2. bookssnob says:

        I’ll take a look when I have a chance, Pat!

  15. Fududnzusu says:

    It is not correct for me forever.

  16. Kathy says:

    I found a very old copy of Morning Shows the Day, I looked on Amazon the only place I could find it and the value shows between 900-1000 dollars? Do you think this could be right?

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s