Harvest by Jim Crace


My first experience of Jim Crace’s writing was when a colleague at the V&A recommended his novel Being Dead for our newly inaugurated staff book club. I wasn’t keen; reading about dead bodies didn’t sound like a thrilling way to spend an evening. However, I was surprised to find a compelling tale that was beautifully written. I had found something special in his style; a clarity and a lyricism that was finely crafted but completely without pretension. As such, I fully intended to read everything else he had written, but as always, life got in the way. So, when Harvest found its way onto the Booker Prize Shortlist, I couldn’t wait to immerse myself in another of his novels at long last.

Set in the rural landscape of pre-industrial Britain, Harvest is the story of a tiny, unnamed community nestled in the timeless folds of England’s green and pleasant land. For years the same people have lived there and farmed its fields, their lives marked and measured by the changing of the seasons. They exist peacefully and harmoniously, their histories and interests inextricably linked, generation after generation. We view them through the eyes of Walter Thirsk,  a relative newcomer to this community, having followed the new Master of the estate to the village upon his marriage to the heiress of the manor a decade previously. Walter has grown to love the land and its people; despite the death of his wife, he has stayed on, grafting his life to those of his neighbours and bending his ways to their routines. Master Kent is their benign, benevolent overseer, an unshowy widower whose own devotion to the land sees him mucking in with those who depend upon him for their livelihood. They want for little and ask for nothing but to be left alone to work their land, indulge their primal desires, and participate in the feasts and festivities that mark the passing of the seasons. This is a simple, unadulterated world, ungoverned even by religion, as they have never bothered to build the church they made a space for many years before.

This idyll is destroyed swiftly over a period of seven days when newcomers arrive and upset the equilibrium of daily life. The arrival of these travellers, accused of stealing doves from the Master, reveals an unexpected darkness at the heart of the villagers that reveals how fear and self interest cannot help but infect even the most simple of lives. At the same time, a man the villagers call Mr Quill also arrives, sent for by Master Kent to draw a map of the open land belonging to the community and parcel it off into sections. Over the next few days, as the newcomers and their transgressions are punished, the realisation dawns that the mapping of the land is foreshadowing a bigger change to come, and the villagers begin to turn on one another in their desire to save themselves, the world we are introduced to at the beginning of the novel falls completely apart.

This is a fascinating, compelling novel that speaks to the human condition and our inherent hatred of change. Crace encourages us to indulge in our feelings of nostalgia and affection for a golden age when people knew their neighbours and were content with their place before carefully deconstructing this image and revealing the reality beneath the surface of such naive idealism. I loved every word; Crace is such a remarkable stylist and his imagery has a power so strong that I felt I was stalking the mud caked lanes of this golden hued pre-industrial world. Of all the novels I have read from the Booker shortlist, this is the one that has stayed with me the longest. It was beautiful but also profoundly disturbing, and I very much hope that this won’t be his last novel, as he has threatened. I have the feeling that his best is still yet to come.



  1. I really want to find time to read this one day. Being dead is one of the few contemporary novels I’ve read twice. (Another is Toni Morrison’s Beloved). I’ve always wanted to read more of his and have never done so, even though most of his books are quite short.

  2. Harvest is on my ‘to read’ pile. After reading this review, I have moved it to the top! I also loved Being Dead, and can highly recommend Signals of Distress too. Can I just point out, by the way, that you have made the same mistake that I made in confusing Jim Crace with the Digested Read author who is JOHN Crace!

    1. Oh my goodness! I can’t believe I have been labouring under such a misapprehension for so long! Isn’t it funny how your brain doesn’t register things like that…I am actually quite disappointed that it’s not him. I thought ‘he’s so clever, he’s so funny’…oh well!

  3. I haven’t felt motivated to read this book yet, but your review is really interesting. Definitely something I need to read and soon.

  4. I loved Harvest – one of Crace’s best, perhaps the best, without a doubt. I wanted it to win the Booker last time. He is such an interesting writer, there is a power behind his words, but not all of the books of his that I’ve read were so easy to get on with for me – I struggled with Quarantine, but adored Arcadia.

    1. I would like to try more of his work, Annabel. I was disappointed that he didn’t win the Booker – he is just the sort of writer who should, and frankly, I thought his novel far more beautifully written and compelling than The Luminaries.

  5. I only got a few pages into this one before I gave up, but I really should give it another try. I loved his novel A Gift of Stones which has similar themes. It’s about a stone age culture that survives by carving tools for their neighbors. One day, a tribe with bronze tools arrives….

  6. I picked this up at the library yesterday. Plan to add it immediately to my “Reading All These Books at the Same Time” pile.

  7. Thanks for your review. Crace is a new author for me. I think I’m going to start with Being Dead. Glad you’re feeling better now. And I see you’re reading “Wake”. I hope to get to that one soon too.

  8. I’d just begun Harvest when I found your lovely blog and so only skimmed the latter til I’d finished reading. Harvest is a wonderfully written book and most engaging story. And I shall certainly be following your recommendations in future and check out previous reviews…..especially now I know there are no spoilers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s