The Happy Tree by Rosalind Murray


This is one of Persephone’s newest batch of books, and is an evocative, sensitively written and powerfully moving novel that was a pure pleasure to read. I raced through it in two sittings, and even found myself having a little cry at the end, which is always a sign of a good book. It is the story of forty something Helen, a thinly fictionalised Rosalind, whose early life set against an idyllic yet rather unconventional background of wealth, intellect and privilege is destroyed by the First World War. She grows up with her two much-loved cousins; confident, talented Guy and sensitive, introverted Hugh, at Yearsley, a beautiful Georgian manor house in the country made up of honey-coloured, flower-filled rooms furnished in faded chintz where it seems to be forever summer. Helen and Hugh share a particular closeness; they understand one another completely, and as they grow older and more self-aware, it is clear that their feelings run much deeper than that of brother and sister. However, this knowledge pushes them apart as they enter their teen years, and unable to manage their emotions, they spend less and less time together. Before long, Helen is left alone as Guy and Hugh go up to Oxford, but after she finishes school, she enjoys being part of their cosmopolitan, intellectual crowd in Oxford and London, where they all gravitate as they enter their twenties.

Life is full of friendship, fun and frivolity, but beneath the surface of this seemingly privileged existence, Helen is haunted by the distance between herself and Hugh. Knowing she cannot have him, she drifts into a relationship with Walter, a rather dry and earnest academic, who, much to the chagrin of her friends and family, she marries. Shortly afterwards, war breaks out, and Helen must watch her beloved cousins and friends go off to fight, while she struggles alone with the responsibility of a growing family in her grotty house in North London. Life, which once seemed so full of beauty and possibility, has irreparably darkened. She doesn’t love Walter, life has become a daily grind of childcare and housework, and the war is a greedy spectre, sucking joy and hope from the world. As the inevitable casualties start to roll in, Helen, consumed with grief and regret, is devastated to realise that her world as she knew it has been destroyed, and there will be no going back.

I think what made me find this book so touching is because really it isn’t about war at all, but more the way in which life often takes us in directions we didn’t plan for, leaving us cast adrift from the vision of the future we believed we would have. There is a tone of such melancholy in Murray’s words, perfectly exemplified when she says ‘And this is all that has happened. It does not seem very much…I was happy when I was a child, and I married the wrong person, and someone I loved dearly was killed in the war…that is all. And all those things must be true of thousands of people.’ The lost opportunities, the private sorrows, the secret grief that courses under the surface of all of the perfectly ordinary people we see every day…it’s really quite an overwhelming thought. As such, The Happy Tree, despite its name, is not exactly an uplifting read, but it’s certainly a thought provoking, searingly honest portrayal of a woman’s life, and I loved every minute. I wish Rosalind Murray’s other novels were easier to come by, as her writing is definitely something I’d love to explore further.


  1. Carla McClure says:

    What a beautifully written review!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Carla! I’m glad you enjoyed it!

  2. As you always do, Rachel, you have captivated me with your review. My TBR list is longer than Pinochio’s nose, but, The Happy Tree is now on it in hopes of one day reading it.

    1. bookssnob says:

      I know you’d love it, Penny!

  3. saffronchilli says:

    Thank you. I have come to trust your recommendations and am so grateful. I will look out for Rosalind Murray now.

    1. bookssnob says:

      That’s a wonderful compliment! I hope you’ll enjoy her writing.

  4. Jessica says:

    I will have to look out for this one – I don’t think I’ve read a wwII narrative from a woman’s perspective of being left at home. This sounds right up my street, thank you!

    1. bookssnob says:

      It’s absolutely fascinating – I’m sure you’d enjoy it!

  5. Mrs Ford says:

    Thank you for this excellent review. This was my first book of 2015, and I too really enjoyed it, inspite of its sadness. You are absolutely right about Helen’s almost disconcerting honesty, especially about her feelings towards her husband, and she is very sharp and sometimes quite funny about her in-laws as well (I particularly enjoyed the appearances of her domineering sister-in-law). And it was very good on the wearing everyday hardships of life in the First World War, as well as its greater tragedies.

    1. bookssnob says:

      I’m glad you enjoyed it too – yes, I loved the description of the sister-in-law too. The passive aggressive controlling nature was perfectly captured! I think it’s a fascinating and very well written novel – definitely a new Persephone favourite.

  6. Jean says:

    Interesting. It looks as if her other novels are available through amazon US. I’m currently reading the biography of writer Penelope Fitzgerald who was married and having children at exactly the same time and whose husband came back psychologically damaged from the war, also something many women had to cope with.

    1. bookssnob says:

      Oh really? I shall have a look. That biography sounds fascinating – I shall look out for it. Thank you, Jean!

  7. Cosy Books says:

    Reading a book in two sittings with a tear or two at the end of it sounds very promising. At some point I’ll be putting a list together for my visit to the shop in May and you’ve done an excellent job of selling this one!

    1. bookssnob says:

      I know you’d love it, Darlene! Is the trip definitely on, then? Exciting!!

  8. janey77 says:

    Excellent! I bought this a while back and it has been collecting dust. I will now most definitely be picking this up for my next read. Best wishes Jane

    1. bookssnob says:

      Oh, you must read it, Janey! It really is wonderful!

  9. joanhunterdunn says:

    Rachel – I finished this book last night & wanted to read your thoughts on it, Lo & behold here they are. It was all I hoped for having read some reviews. That final sentence is wonderful.
    Hope 2015 is being kind to you x

    1. bookssnob says:

      Serendipity, Rachel! 🙂 I am so glad you enjoyed it – it is such a beautiful book, and yes, that final sentence – it just took my breath away a little in its honesty. I love books that hold that power. Thank you – same to you! x

  10. BookerTalk says:

    Sounds a wonderful book and since it’s persephone I bet it is a pleasure to look at also

    1. bookssnob says:

      Yes – wonderful to read and to have on the shelf!

  11. Vipula says:

    The review is so tremendous that it made me so terribly sad just reading what the book is about. I have to order my copy now!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Vipula – I hope you’ll enjoy it!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s