Islanders by Helen Hull

Helen Hull is my current literary heroine. Her books are practically all out of print and she is largely forgotten, but this sad state of affairs bears absolutely no relation to her talent. Islanders is the third of her books that I have read, and once again I was blown away by her atmospheric, emotive writing that is so insightful about humanity. The closest author I can compare her to is probably Dorothy Whipple, in the sense that her books focus very much on the domestic, family environment and women’s role within it, though she is also very like Dorothy Canfield in her compassionate and wise understanding of women, and also like Willa Cather in her clear, uncluttered, evocative prose that so effortlessly brings to life the barren clapboard and dirt road landscape of the 19th century American Mid-West.

Islanders is the story of Ellen Dacey, who, when the novel opens, is a teenager living in a small Mid Western town in the 1840s. She is engaged to Matthew, a neighbour, but their marriage is being postponed while he, along with Ellen’s older brother Rob and a group of other men from their town, are going out West to try and strike their fortune in the gold mines. They plan to go for a year, earn the type of money they could never dream of making from their farms, and then come back triumphant, able to revitalise their backwater town. Ellen is sceptical; she sees no reason for them to go, and she hates Matthew for it. Just when she was looking forward to a life and a home of her own, she is left with her ageing parents and younger brother to hold the fort while the young men get to go and have the adventures she longs for. However, the situation is worse than Ellen fears; her father Thurston Senior plans to ride out with the boys to the point where they will be met by the wagon trail. When he doesn’t return after two days, they begin to worry. Then a messenger boy comes; Thurston couldn’t resist the call to adventure – he has gone along with them. Ellen’s long suffering mother Martha swallows her pain and anger at being left behind and throws herself into managing the farm, expecting Ellen and Sarah, Rob’s pregnant wife, to do the same. Life must go on, and there is work to do.

A year passes; the men fail to return. The years continue to pass, becoming a decade, then fifteen years, then sixteen, with still no word from the men. Ellen and Martha have formed a self sufficient life and the farm flourishes under Ellen’s keen eye for business. Then, completely by surprise, Thurston Senior returns home nearly twenty years after he left, with nothing but a few nuggets of gold in his pocket and the expectation that he will take back control of his land. His return is a double blow to Ellen; not only does it destroy her independence, but also her hope of marriage, as she must finally accept that Matthew is never coming back. Shortly afterwards, Martha dies and Thurston Junior wrests control of the farm from Ellen and his father, demanding that they move in with his family. At nearly 40, Ellen is forced out of her beloved home and taken from the farm work that she finds so deeply satisfying. Thurston’s lazy, snobbish wife Grace uses her as a maid and a nanny to her children, Robbie, Alice and John Thurston, but far from resenting this, Ellen comes to relish her role as an aunt. Robbed of the chance to become a wife and mother, she sensitively and tenderly cares for her nephews and niece, particularly doting on Robbie. When Civil War is declared, again the men ride off,  leaving Ellen to keep everything going. When the men return, she must retreat into the background like she did before, important only to the children.

As time goes on, and people age, change, move away and die, Ellen’s life remains the same. As new generations are born and grow up, Ellen becomes ever more frustrated at the ‘islands’ she perceives that she and the other women in her family are forced to live upon. They are left stranded at home in their own self contained, limited worlds, becoming variously soft, ineffectual and desperate as their dreams and hopes are squandered while their men are free to go and pursue their dreams, make their fortunes and dictate the course of the women’s lives. Ellen has made the best of things; she has been the solid foundation for the rest of her family, supporting them through tragedy and turmoil, never complaining about her lot. Inside, though, she has been railing against her situation, determined to see the day when women can be more than just dependents and leave the islands they have been trapped upon.

This is such a fantastic novel. Set across three generations, with Ellen as the lynchpin between them, it is a remarkable picture of women’s lives during a rapidly changing period in American history. Hull creates in Ellen a beautiful, brave woman whose capacity for endurance is almost superhuman. She doesn’t let her disappointment and her frustration colour her life; instead, she takes each day as it comes, influencing what she can and making the most of every opportunity she has: a true feminist. She comes alive on the page, as does the world she lives in; from mid 19th century pioneer town to turn of the century New York, Hull creates a sense of place that echoes variously both Ellen’s sense of entrapment as well as the expansive nature of her soul. It is beautifully written and  totally absorbing; I loved every minute of reading it. Islanders has been reprinted by the Feminist Press and is available from the Book Depository postage free, so none of you have any excuse not to read it!!


  1. i love your site, and your wide choice of books, and although american history i not what i would usually read, you write with so much clarity, enthusiasm and detail that i may just have to read this.. thank you!

    1. bookssnob says:

      Thanks Shrinking Tree! I think most people who read this blog aren’t massively into American literature, but they are missing out! I so enjoyed discovering the wide variety of American experiences depicted in literature when I lived there and I wish more people would do the same! I hope you do go on to read this novel – it really is wonderful!

  2. CFisher says:

    As soon as I read the first sentence and saw the words “largely forgotten” I knew I was going to enjoy your blog. I don’t know if it’s ironic or not but the Internet seems to have done more for forgotten, out-of-the-way or old fashioned writers than any number of new and best selling authors. I look forward to reading more.

    1. bookssnob says:

      I’m glad you are of the same persuasion! It never ceases to amaze me how many fantastic writers have gone out of print. The internet is helping to resurrect them, you’re absolutely right – and there seems to be a growing number of small presses bringing them back into the light of day too. As technology advances, the more we want to dig up the past, it seems! I hope you’ll give this a go!

      1. CFisher says:

        Now with print on demand it’s so much easier to republish old books. Please do drop by my blog when you can. So far I’ve not written about a book published later than the 1920s!

  3. Marie says:

    I have to be honest and admit that I usually steer clear of epic historical sagas, however your review is excellent and I am very tempted to sniff out a copy of this! I probably won’t rush out to buy it just yet but it just goes to show the power of a great review.


    1. bookssnob says:

      I wouldn’t say this was a historical saga…more the story of a woman’s life and the effects of social and historical change on the way she lives it and her hopes for the future. There’s not a lot of period detail in there – it’s very introspective. I hope you will give it a try – I’m glad I’ve tempted you!!

  4. Jo says:

    You always review books in a way which makes me think I have to have this now!! My TBR pile is now a mountain because that is usually what I do. Don’t stop, because if it wasn’t for you I would have missed so much. My copies of ‘Joanna and Ulysses’ and ‘A Favourite of the Gods’ arrived today, roll on the summer holidays, I have serious reading to do. It was supposed to be done in the garden though, not in front of the fire.

    1. bookssnob says:

      It makes me so happy that you buy books on the strength of my reviews, Jo – even if it does mean you have an out of control TBR pile!! I certainly won’t be stopping! 😉 I’m thrilled you have copies of Joanna and Ulysses and A Favourite of the Gods to read – I’m sure you will love them. Please come and tell me what you think of them!

  5. Kathy says:

    Hey Rachel: Great review, thanks. Islanders is one of two of my Hulls I have not yet read, so I enjoyed hearing about it. I have not seen her use a 19th C setting, that will be interesting. Sounds like this is one of her particularly strong novels, different story, using some of her major themes. Kathy aka Ruby

    1. bookssnob says:

      Oh Kathy, I’m sure you’ll love it. I think it’s a very strong novel – possibly better than Heat Lightning – and just brilliant. Get to it soon!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s